Whales need ‘useless’ hip bones for sex

"Everyone's always assumed that if you gave whales and dolphins a few more million years of evolution, the pelvic bones would disappear. But it appears that's not the case," says Matthew Dean. (Credit: CityTalk城市通/Flickr)

Far from being vestigial, whale hip bones play a key role in reproduction. The finding flies in the face of the assumption that the pelvic bones are useless.

Not only do the bones serve a purpose, but their size and possibly shape are influenced by the forces of sexual selection.

Both whales and dolphins have pelvic (hip) bones, evolutionary remnants from when their ancestors walked on land more than 40 million years ago. Common wisdom has long held that those bones are simply vestigial, slowly withering away like tailbones on humans.

Matt Dean and Jim Dines hold whale bones
Matt Dean (left) holds a box containing a dolphin skeleton and Jim Dines (right) holds up the pelvic bones. (Credit: Gus Ruelas/USC)

“Everyone’s always assumed that if you gave whales and dolphins a few more million years of evolution, the pelvic bones would disappear. But it appears that’s not the case,” says Matthew Dean, assistant professor at the University of Southern California’s Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences, and co-corresponding author of the paper published by the journal Evolution.

Dean collaborated with fellow co-corresponding author Jim Dines, Collections Manager of Mammalogy at the Natural History Museum (NHM) of Los Angeles County and one-time a graduate student in Dean’s lab, on a painstaking four-year project to analyze cetacean—whale and dolphin—pelvic bones.

Hip bones and mobility

The muscles that control a cetacean’s penis—which has a high degree of mobility—attach directly to its pelvic bones. As such, it made sense to Dean and Dines that the pelvic bones could affect the level of control over the penis that an individual cetacean has, perhaps offering an evolutionary advantage.


To test this hypothesis, they examined hundreds of pelvic bones—first at the NHM, which has the second-largest collection of marine mammal specimens in North America; and then at the Smithsonian Institution, which has the largest.

“Cetacean skeletons are stored as boxes of bones on warehouse shelves, with each box containing an individual specimen. You have to comb through each box looking for the specific bone you need. The pelvic bones are comparatively small and aren’t always collected with the rest of the skeleton, but after the first couple hundred boxes we got very good at finding them when they were present,” says Dines.

Using a 3D laser scanner, they created digital models of the curved bones, offering an unprecedented level of detail about their shape and size, as well as giving them the option to computationally manipulate them—say, to compare two different bones.

Evolutionary balance

Next, they gathered reams of data going as far back as the days of whalers about testis size relative to body mass in whales. Throughout nature, more “promiscuous” animal species—that is, those with females who mate with several males, creating a more competitive mating environment—develop larger testes relative to their body mass as a way of outperforming the competition.

Finally, they compared the size of the pelvic bones (relative to body size) to the size of the animal’s testis (again, relative to body size). The results were clear: the bigger the relative testis, the bigger the relative pelvic bone—meaning that more competitive mating environments seem to drive the evolution of larger pelvic bones. Males from more promiscuous species also evolve larger penises, so larger pelvic bones appear necessary to attach larger muscles for penis control.

As a negative control, Dean and Dines also compared testis size to the size of one of the animal’s ribs. If pelvic bone size were simply a reflection of overall skeletal size, there should be a corresponding correlation in the ribs—but there was not, strengthening the interpretation that whale pelvic bones are specifically targeted by selection related to mating system.

“Our research really changes the way we think about the evolution of whale pelvic bones in particular, but more generally about structures we call ‘vestigial.’ As a parallel, we are now learning that our appendix is actually quite important in several immune processes, not a functionally useless structure,” Dean says.

3D  copies

Over the course of their four-year project, the team created a new way of measuring and quantifying the complicated 3D structures of bones, using laser scanners to generate 3D images of the bones and developing novel computational methods to analyze bones that lack obvious landmarks.

The process has significant potential for the recording and study of bones by museums, Dines says.

When doing their data collection, the team had to request loans from the Smithsonian and several other museums, which would ship out the bones themselves for study. However, if all specimens were recorded using Dean and Dines’ system, digital copies could be sent anywhere in the world for free—without risking the loss or damage of the original specimen. The data that Dean and Dines collected are detailed enough to generate 3D printed versions of the bones, if desired.

“Cutting edge imaging technologies like 3D laser scanning are revolutionizing how museum collections are used. Not only do they give us a new way of analyzing bones and other specimens, they also allow us to make precise replicas of those specimens. The replicas can then, for example, be sent to colleagues abroad or placed on exhibit while the original specimen stays in the museum researcher’s lab for further study,” Dines says.

Dean and Dine’s collaborators in this effort includes E. Otarola-Castillo of Iowa State University.

USC startup funds, the National Institutes of Health, and the William Cheney, Jr. Memorial Fund for Mammalogy helped support the project.

Source: University of Southern California