Ceramic pots may ‘remember’ ancient meals

The residue in these seven La Chamba pots retained evidence of all the meals prepared in them. (Credit: Melanie Miller)

Unglazed ceramic cookware can retain the residue of the last meal someone cooked in it, as well as that of previous meals, archaeologists report.

The findings, reported in the journal Scientific Reports, suggest that gastronomic practices going back millennia—say, to cook Aztec turkey, hominy pozole, or the bean stew likely served at the Last Supper—can be reconstructed by analyzing the chemical compounds adhering to and absorbed by the earthenware in which they were prepared.

“Our data can help us better reconstruct the meals and specific ingredients that people consumed in the past which, in turn, can shed light on social, political and environmental relationships within ancient communities,” says study co-lead author Melanie Miller, a researcher at the University of California, Berkeley’s Archaeological Research Facility and a postdoctoral scholar at the University of Otago in New Zealand.

In a yearlong cooking experiment that Miller and archaeologist Christine Hastorf led, seven chefs each prepared 50 meals made from combinations of venison, maize (corn), and wheat flour in newly purchased La Chamba ceramic pots. This robust, burnished black clay cookware dates back to pre-Columbian South America, and the handcrafted vessels remain popular for preparing and serving traditional foods today.

The group came up with the idea in Hastorf’s Archaeology of Food graduate seminar. By analyzing the chemical residues of the meals cooked in each pot, the researchers sought to learn whether the deposits found in ancient cooking vessels would reflect the remains of only the last dish cooked, or previous meals, as well.

In addition to receiving donated deer roadkill, they purchased large quantities of whole grains and a mill, which Hastorf set up in her garage, to grind them. The group then developed a repertoire of six recipes using deer meat and whole and milled grain.

They picked staple ingredients that could be found in many parts of the world. For example, two recipes focused on hominy, which is made from soaking maize in an alkaline solution, while two others used wheat flour.

“We chose the food based on how easy it would be to distinguish the chemicals in the food from one another and how the pots would react to the isotopic and chemical values of the food,” says Hastorf, a professor of anthropology who studies food archaeology.

Each of the seven chefs cooked an experimental meal weekly in a La Chamba pot using the group’s designated ingredients. “The mushy meals were bland, and we didn’t eat them,” Miller notes.

Every eighth meal was charred to replicate the kinds of carbonized residues that archaeologists often encounter in ancient pots and to mimic what would normally happen in a pot’s lifetime. Between each meal, the pots were cleaned with water and a branch from an apple tree. Surprisingly, none of them broke during the course of the study.

At Berkeley’s Center for Stable Isotope Biogeochemisty, the team conducted an analysis of the charred remains and the carbonized patinas that developed on the pots. Stable isotopes are atoms whose composition does not decay over time, which is useful for archaeological studies. An analysis of the fatty lipids absorbed into the clay cookware took place at the University of Bristol in England.

Overall, chemical analyses of the food residues showed that different meal time scales were represented in different residues. For example, the charred bits at the bottom of a pot contained evidence of the latest meal cooked, while the remnants of prior meals could be found in the patina that built up elsewhere on the pot’s interior, and in the lipid residue that was absorbed into the pottery itself.

These results give scientists a new tool to study long-ago diets and also provide clues to food production, supply, and distribution chains of past eras.

“We’ve flung open the door for others to take this experiment to the next level and record even longer timelines in which food residues can be identified,” Miller says.

Coauthors are from UC Berkeley, the University of Bristol, the Bernice Pauahi Bishop Museum in Hawai’i, the University of Southern California; and the University of Hawai’i-West O’ahu.

Source: UC Berkeley