Traits we can’t see can help us find stuff in clutter

(Credit: Charos Pix/Flickr)

Anyone who’s ever tried to find something in a hurry knows how helpful it is to think about the lost item’s color, size, and shape. Invisible traits matter, too, say researchers.

When the researchers asked participants in their new study to spot everyday objects in clutter, they found them about 20% faster if they could factor in latent physical traits like hardness or softness—even though people had no idea that they were considering those factors.

“What makes the finding particularly striking from a vision science standpoint is that simply knowing the latent physical properties of objects is enough to help guide your attention to them,” says senior author Jason Fischer, a cognitive neuroscientist in the psychological and brain sciences department at Johns Hopkins University.

“It’s surprising because nearly all prior research in this area has focused on a host of visual properties that can facilitate search, but we find that what you know about objects can be as important as what you actually see.”

Fischer’s Dynamic Perception Lab studies how people’s intuitive understanding of physical properties and dynamics influences how they interact with their everyday environments, and also how people focus on the things they need to when there is so much to see in the world at any given moment. Those lines of research come together here, as the team wondered if someone’s knowledge of objects’ physical attributes would influence their attention in a visual search.

For instance, people know through experience that eggs are light and fragile, and canned products are heavy and sturdy. When bagging those things at the grocery store, people would likely put the heavy cans at the bottom of a bag and the fragile eggs on top. But if you can’t see the fragility or the heaviness, you just inherently know it, would that knowledge help you find something?

To get at the answer, lead author Li Guo, a graduate student, ran a series of visual search experiments where the researchers asked people to locate everyday objects amid clutter. The target was sometimes differentiated by its hardness. Guo and the team found that participants implicitly used the hardness distinction to locate a target more quickly, even though none reported being aware that hardness was relevant.

“You’re automatically leveraging what you know about hardness to avoid being distracted by the other things,” Guo says.

“If you are searching for a sweater in a cluttered room, without any awareness of doing so you are able to avoid wasting time searching through the hard objects in the room and instead focus on the soft ones,” Fischer says.

The more items in the search, the greater the benefit of being able to differentiate them through hardness, the researchers found. The benefit existed even when participants were shown line drawings. And when the team tracked where participants looked while searching, they found that participants wasted less time looking at objects that didn’t have the correct hardness or softness.

“To me what this says is that in the back of our minds, we are always evaluating the physical content of a scene to decide what to do next,” Fischer says.

“Our mental intuitive physics engines are constantly at work to guide not only how we interact with things in our environment, but how we distribute our attention among them as well.”

The team hopes to build on these findings by studying how what people intuitively know about the physics of objects might help them predict what’s going to happen next in an environment.

The findings appear in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General.

Source: Johns Hopkins University