Open relationships vary—as do their odds of working

(Credit: Getty Images)

Can an open relationship work? New research—which identifies five types of such nonmonogamous arrangements—says it depends.

Open relationships typically describe couples in which the partners have agreed on sexual activity with someone other than their primary romantic partner, while maintaining the couple bond.

“We know that communication is helpful to all couples,” says Ronald Rogge, an associate professor of psychology at the University of Rochester and head of the Rogge Lab, where the research took place.

“However, it is critical for couples in nonmonogamous relationships as they navigate the extra challenges of maintaining a nontraditional relationship in a monogamy-dominated culture. Secrecy surrounding sexual activity with others can all too easily become toxic and lead to feelings of neglect, insecurity, rejection, jealousy, and betrayal, even in nonmonogamous relationships.”

Open relationships vary

Past studies have attempted to gauge the success of nonmonogamous relationships. But the critical difference this time is that the research team considered distinctions and nuances within various types of nonmonogamous relationships, and then assessed the success of each type independently.

As a result, their findings indicate no blanket conclusions about the prospects of nonmonogamous relationships; instead, the research, published in the Journal of Sex Research, suggests conditions under which nonmonogamous relationships tend to succeed, and those under which relationships become strained.

Rogge and colleagues analyzed responses from 1,658 online questionnaires. Among the respondents a majority (67.5%) were in their 20s and 30s, 78% of participants were white, nearly 70% identified as female, and most were in long-term relationships (on average nearly 4.5 years). The team assessed three key dimensions for each relationship—applying what they call the “Triple-C Model” of mutual consent, communication, and comfort.

5 kinds of open relationships

Significantly, they divided study participants into five distinct classes of relationships:

  • Two monogamous groups, representing earlier- and later-stage monogamous relationships
  • Consensual nonmonogamous (CNM) relationships, marked by low interest in monogamy and high levels of mutual consent, comfort, and communication around commitment and sexual activity with a person other than the primary partner
  • Partially open relationships, with more mixed attitudes toward monogamy and lower consent, comfort, and communication
  • One-sided sexual relationships with a person besides the primary partner, in which one partner desires monogamy while the other partner engages in sex outside the existing relationship with low levels of mutual consent, comfort, and almost no communication between the couple about sex outside the relationship.

The team discovered that monogamous and consensual nonmonogamous (CNM) groups demonstrated high levels of functioning in their relationships and as individuals, whereas the partially open and one-sided nonmonogamous groups exhibited lower functioning.

People in both monogamous groups reported relatively healthy relationships, as well as some of the lowest levels of loneliness and psychological distress. Both monogamous groups and the consensual nonmonogamous group (CNM) reported similarly low levels of loneliness and distress, and similarly high satisfaction levels in regards to need, relationship, and sex.

Moreover, both monogamous groups reported the lowest levels of sexual sensation seeking, indicating fairly restrained and mainstream attitudes towards casual sex.

Overall, people in the three nonmonogamous relationships reported high levels of sexual sensation seeking, were more likely to actively look for new sexual partners, and to have contracted a sexually transmitted disease.

Flowchart steps through a four-step process. Step 1: How aware is your partner of your sexual activity with others. The options are Not At All, A Little, Somewhat, Quite a Bit, Very Much, and Extremely. For the Not at All and A Little Options, the flowchat moves to the next step, "What is the commitment structure of your relationship? There are two options there, 'Exclusive/Monagamous and All Other Responses. For the Very Much and Extremely Options in step one, the flow chart goes to the next step, How much does your partner believe in monogamy or desire a monogamous relationship? On set of answers says Not At All, A Little, or Somewhat. And another set of answers says Quite a Bit, Very Much, and Extremely. Each of these five paths point down to a row at the bottom of the chart that represents a continuum of relationship functioning success, with from High to Low.
(Credit: Michael Osadciw/U. Rochester)

Sex, sexuality, and feelings

Yet, each of the three nonmonogamous groups varied in significant ways.

People in the consensual nonmonogamous group (CNM) were in fairly long-term relationships (and had the highest proportion among all five groups of people living with their partner, followed closely by the monogamous group with minimal recent sex outside their relationship).

The consensual nonmonogamous group also had the highest number of heteroflexible (primarily heterosexual but open to sex with same-sex partners) and bisexual respondents, suggesting that individuals in the LGBT community might be more comfortable with nontraditional relationship structures.

By contrast, people in partially open and one-sided nonmonogamous relationships tended to be in younger relationships, reported lower levels of dedication to their relationships, and low levels of affection. Few reported high sexual satisfaction, and they had the highest rates of condomless sex with new partners.

The groups of partially open and one-sided nonmonogamous relationships also showed some of the highest levels of discomfort with emotional attachment (also called attachment avoidance), psychological distress, and loneliness.

Which open relationships have the best shot?

Overall, the one-sided group fared worst of all, with the highest proportion of people significantly dissatisfied with their relationships: 60%—nearly three times as high as the monogamous or the consensual nonmonogamous group.

Rogge cautions that the authors looked at cross-sectional data only, which meant they were unable to directly track relationships failing over time.

While the data clearly show that not all nonmonogamous relationships are equal—one rule applies to all:

“Sexual activity with someone else besides the primary partner, without mutual consent, comfort, or communication can easily be understood as a form of betrayal or cheating,” says Hangen. “And that, understandably, can seriously undermine or jeopardize the relationship.”

Support for the study came from the National Science Foundation Graduate Fellowship, and the Department of Veteran Affairs’ Office of Academic Affiliations Advanced Fellowship Program in Mental Illness Research and Treatment.

Source: University of Rochester