Model clarifies individual epilepsy seizure ‘clock’

"The data shows that with age, patients have shorter cycles. It seems like an obvious thing, but the link had not been formally established," says Marina Vannucci. (Credit: Adriano Pucciarelli/Unsplash)

Epileptic seizures happen like clockwork, but depend on the clock, research shows.

Researchers sought to formalize how those clocks tick to give people with epilepsy a better idea of how and why their seizures happen, and perhaps to better recognize the early warnings.

In the process, they established that aging itself, as well as common triggers, may be contributing factors to how the disease affects those prone to seizures.

The study appears in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Epilepsy is a disorder in which surges of electrical activity in the brain cause seizures. Often, these seizures are cyclical and can be triggered by many events. But why different patients experience seizure cycles of different lengths is unknown.

“We developed a new statistical model to explicitly capture the effect of factors that may drive transitions in seizure risk,” says Sharon Chiang, clinical instructor and research fellow at the University of California, San Francisco. “We looked at anti-seizure medications and different triggers like illness and menstrual cycles. Those are some of the factors commonly thought to increase or decrease seizure risk.

“The relationship of cycle length to age was an interesting finding,” she says. “We’re able to see there are shorter cycles in older age groups and then longer cycles in younger age groups. A shortening of cycle length with age may have potential ramifications in future clinical practice.”

In earlier studies, the group analyzed patients’ seizure diaries to assess their seizure risks and looked at brain scans to find markers for patients with epilepsy most likely to benefit from brain surgery.

The new work by Chiang, her mentor Marina Vannucci, and lead author Emily Wang, who earned her PhD at Rice this year, seeks to emphasize the importance of logging seizures—and their absence—daily and over the long term. That will help establish individual chronotypes, or rhythms, for patients who experience seizures in cycles and wish to understand why seizures happen when they do, what may trigger them, and how best to treat them.

An online diary that tracks seizure activity both simplifies the process for patients and provides the researchers with a wealth of data to mine for their statistical dynamical systems models, the “dynamic” part capturing change over time. Seizure Tracker, founded by coauthor Robert Moss, provides tools to help patients, doctors, and researchers understand relationships between seizure activity and therapies that will improve patient care.

For the current study, the logs of more than 1,000 patients ages 2 months to 80 years helped the team model the relationship between “attractor states,” internal and/or external events like the start of a new medication or an illness, and the peaks and valleys of seizure activity in an individual patient.

“The purpose of this model is to try to guide the patient and the doctor, in particular,” says Vannucci, professor of statistics at Rice University’s George R. Brown School of Engineering. “We want to help doctors say, ‘OK, this medication is really important for this patient with this type of seizure,’ and control their seizures in a better way.”

The relevance of a patient’s age emerged from Seizure Tracker data as well. “Calm stretches between seizures seem to get shorter for patients as they get older,” Vannucci notes.

“Triggers and age are the two factors we found to be significant for the change of attractor states,” she says. “The data shows that with age, patients have shorter cycles. It seems like an obvious thing, but the link had not been formally established.”

The data are accurate for patients who can recognize and log in each seizure every day, but the researchers know people aren’t always able to do so. That’s where the team’s background in Bayesian modeling helps to fill the gaps.

Vannucci says the new study is the product of research that began in 2017. “Doctors and patients sit down and see when their seizure frequency is going up or down or is stable,” she says. “We realized we can formalize in a statistical model attractors and latent states and infer the changes over states.”

That resulted in a 2018 Epilepsia Open study that suggested a Bayesian model could better define seizure risks for patients. From there, she says the team incorporated attractors and other covariates like medications to build the model detailed in the current study.

“We hope this study is the best of all and the most helpful for patients and doctors,” Vannucci says.

Coauthors of the paper are from Baylor College of Medicine and the Michael E. DeBakey Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Houston, as well as UCSF.

The Gulf Coast Consortia’s National Library of Medicine Training Program in Biomedical Informatics and Data Science and the National Institutes of Health supported the research.

Source: Rice University