New research finds that about 1 in 4 young adults surveyed overestimated their financial understanding, a disconnect that could help educators rethink how financial literacy is taught.
How much do you know about managing your finances? And how much do you think you know?
The new study in the Journal of Consumer Affairs by University of Georgia researchers found that young adults’ confidence in their financial knowledge doesn’t always reflect what they actually know, a disconnect that could help educators rethink how financial literacy is taught.
“Feeling knowledgeable doesn’t necessarily translate into making well-informed financial decisions,” says Travis Mountain, co-author of the study and a University of Georgia Cooperative Extension financial planning specialist in the College of Family and Consumer Sciences.
The findings are based on data from the 2021 National Financial Capability Study, which analyzed the responses of more than 7,000 adults aged 18 to 34. Questions covered topics such as interest rates, inflation, mortgages, and investing.
Using a statistical approach that considered participants’ self-assessments, correct answers, and willingness to acknowledge uncertainty, the researchers identified four distinct groups: consistently high knowledge, overconfident, reluctant to answer, and consistently low knowledge. About 1 in 4 participants fell into the overconfident group.
“What’s interesting is how closely that group’s confidence resembled the confidence of participants who demonstrated much stronger financial knowledge,” says Mountain.
Both groups rated their understanding of personal finance highly, with the overconfident group giving itself slightly higher marks. But when it came to answering financial questions, the difference was significant.
Participants with consistently high knowledge answered an average of 5.1 out of seven questions correctly, while those classified as overconfident averaged just 2.5.
Mountain says that difference is why taking a person’s confidence at face value is unreliable for measuring financial understanding.
The other aspect of the research that interested Mountain was the distinction between those who answered “I don’t know” and those who gave incorrect answers.
“Someone who gives an incorrect answer may be different from someone who recognizes that they don’t know the answer, and we wanted to preserve that distinction,” Mountain says.
The findings offer a new way to think about financial literacy, one that considers both what people know and how well they understand their own limitations.
The study suggests that people with similar financial knowledge scores may need different kinds of support. Someone who recognizes they don’t understand a financial concept may approach learning differently than someone who believes they’ve mastered it. Recognizing this difference could help financial educators tailor their instruction more effectively.
“Financial education should help people understand both the material and the limits of their knowledge,” Mountain explained. “We want people to feel comfortable making financial decisions, but we also want that confidence to be supported by true understanding.”
Working through real-world examples with opportunities for feedback can help people identify gaps in their understanding before making financial decisions.
“Consider someone comparing two loan offers,” says Mountain. “They might understand what an interest rate is but struggle to calculate the total cost of borrowing or determine which option is less expensive over time.”
When comparing loan terms, evaluating an investment, or making a major purchase, it’s worth checking what you understand and asking questions about what you don’t.
Source: University of Georgia