New studies debunk the second most-watched TED talk ever—the one about how “power poses” can improve your life.
“This new evidence joins an existing body of research questioning the claim by power pose advocates that making your body more physically expansive—such as standing with your legs spread and your hands on your hips—can actually make you more likely to succeed in life,” says Joseph Cesario, associate professor of psychology at Michigan State University.
Cesario co-edits a scientific journal, Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology, that recently published seven studies, all of which attempted—unsuccessfully—to replicate and extend the effects of power pose research.
“Feeling powerful may feel good, but on its own does not translate into powerful or effective behaviors.”
In other words, none of the studies showed positive effects of power poses on any behavioral measure, such as how well you perform in a job interview. Dana Carney, a University of California, Berkeley professor who was one of the authors of the original power pose research, even reviewed the studies.
In addition, Cesario and Michigan State graduate student David Johnson recently published four new studies testing whether holding power poses affected important behaviors such as how well you do in a business negotiation. The work, published in the journal Social Psychological and Personality Science, again found no evidence that making yourself expansive mattered at all.
“There is currently little reason to continue to strongly believe,” Cesario says, “that holding these expansive poses will meaningfully affect people’s lives, especially the lives of the low-status or powerless people.”
Led by Carney and Amy Cuddy from Harvard University, the original power pose study, in 2010, suggested that holding such poses can make you more likely to succeed in life, especially if you are “chronically powerless because of lack of resources, low hierarchical rank, or membership in a low-power social group.”
Cuddy’s June 2012 TED talk, now with more than 42 million views, argued that “power posing”—or standing in a posture of confidence, even when we don’t feel confident—will boost feelings of confidence and will have an impact on one’s chances for success, such as in a job interview.
When you’re alone before the interview, Cuddy recommends, hold a power pose for two minutes—whether that’s standing with hands on hips, leaning over a table with your fingertips on the surface, or perhaps seated with your feet on the table and your arms folded behind your head.
“Share [this science] with people, because the people who can use it the most are the ones with no resources and no technology and no status and no power,” Cuddy concludes the TED talk. “Give it to them because they can do it in private. They need their bodies, privacy, and two minutes, and it can significantly change the outcomes of their life.”
But the new research stands in stark contrast to Cuddy’s claim. Cesario’s research and the findings from the journal he co-edits do find that holding power poses makes people feel more powerful, but that’s where the effect ends.
“Feeling powerful may feel good, but on its own does not translate into powerful or effective behaviors,” Cesario says. “These new studies, with more total participants than nearly every other study on the topic, show—unequivocally—that power poses have no effects on any behavioral or cognitive measure.”
In several of the experiments by Cesario and Johnson, for example, participants watched Cuddy’s TED talk, held a power pose, and then completed a negotiation task with another participant. The participants who held the power poses did no better than their partners.
In addition, the seven studies that appear in a special issue of Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology also fail to replicate the power pose effects.
“Based on the papers in the special issue, and prior replication attempts, one could conclude that the power pose effect on behavioral outcomes does not replicate,” the researchers, including Cesario and Dana Carney, write in the journal.
Carney puts it even more bluntly in a previously posted statement on her website: “As evidence has come in over these past two-plus years, my views have updated to reflect the evidence. As such, I do not believe that power pose effects are real.”
Source: Michigan State University