health care

Will the Affordable Care Act hurt veterans?

UC DAVIS (US) — An expert says that veterans may suffer unintended negative consequences of the Affordable Care Act.

The Affordable Care Act will expand health insurance coverage for low-income persons through Medicaid and state health-insurance exchanges, including much-needed care for 1.8 million uninsured veterans in the U.S.

However, the new insurance coverage option may have a number of unintended negative effects on health care for veterans, says Kenneth W. Kizer, director of the Institute for Population Health Improvement at the University of California, Davis.


His viewpoint, including recommendations for evaluating services in preparation for 2014, appears in the Journal of the American Medical Association.

“The Affordable Care Act will not affect health care for the majority of veterans differently than it will affect nonveterans, and it will not change eligibility for VA health care, covered benefits, co-payment for services, or how the VA health-care system is administered or operated,” Kizer says.

“But it will affect health care for many veterans through its effects on access, fragmentation and quality of care, utilization of services, the health-care workforce, and cost.

“We need to define and quantify the potential impacts that additional health-insurance choices from the Affordable Care Act will have on the delivery of health-care services for veterans in 2014.”

A former undersecretary for health in the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and a veteran of the U.S. Navy, Kizer engineered the transformation of the VA health care system, including the deployment of a system-wide electronic health record and a comprehensive quality improvement and performance management system.

The health insurance plans for the nation’s 22 million military veterans fall into three categories. The majority, 56 percent, have private health insurance or are covered by a non-VA health plan. Thirty-seven percent receive health-care services through the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) health care system, which bases eligibility on having a service-connected disability, low-income level, and net worth or other specific circumstances.

More than 80 percent of VA enrollees older than 65 years also are covered by Medicare, and about 25 percent are beneficiaries of two or more non-VA-federal health plans, such as Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, or Indian Health Service. Seven percent of veterans have no health insurance.

The Affordable Care Act will expand health-care choices and potentially increase convenience and timeliness of care for veterans, but Kizer believes that having more health-insurance options can also cause fragmentation, diminishing continuity and coordination of care, resulting in more emergency department use, hospitalizations, diagnostic interventions, and adverse events.

He believes it also may shift care from VA facilities with experienced staff to private practice physicians who may be less prepared to treat conditions prevalent among veterans, and potentially result in decreased use of VA facilities, endangering volume-sensitive services, such as intensive care or complex surgery, which can affect local access to care and some health-care worker training programs.

In addition, with more than 30 million newly insured persons nationwide seeking services, some VA and non-VA facilities in rural and medically underserved areas already struggling with health-care worker and specialist shortages may be overwhelmed with increased demands for care.

According to Kizer, increasing health-insurance options for VA health-care enrollees will also increase redundant spending for veterans’ health care.

“In 2009, the VA spent $3.2 billion to care for nearly 775,000 veterans who were also enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans,” Kizer says. “These expenditures were overwhelmingly for routine inpatient and outpatient care covered by the Medicare Advantage plan, but federal law precludes the VA from being reimbursed for services provided to Medicare Advantage beneficiaries. As a result, the federal government paid twice for care of the same person in many instances.”

Kizer has three recommendations to streamline services and costs in preparation for the post-Affordable Care Act health-care environment, the first of which is to comprehensively evaluate and prioritize solutions for coordinating VA and non-VA health-care resources for veterans.

Second, assess current and projected VA health-care workforce needs and service utilization vulnerabilities, including expansion of telehealth and home-care services, and third, develop a shared vision for veteran’s health care considering its role as a safety net provider, the declining numbers of World War II and Vietnam War veterans, the increasing number of female veterans, and variables affecting federal funding.

More news from UC Davis:

Related Articles