To find where rock melts, go deeper

RICE (US) — Magma melts hotter and deeper in the Earth than previously thought, a finding that scientists say explains several long-standing puzzles.

For a new study published in the journal Nature, researchers put very small samples of peridotite under very large pressures to discover that rock can and does liquify, at least in small amounts, as deep as 250 kilometers in the mantle beneath the ocean floor.

The mantle is the planet’s middle layer, a buffer of rock between the crust—the top 5 miles or so—and the core. If one could compress millions of years of observation down to minutes, the mantle would look like a rolling mass of rising and falling material. This slow but constant convection brings materials from deep within the planet to the surface—and occasionally higher through volcanoes.

Geologist Rajdeep Dasgupta uses powerful hydraulic presses to crush rock samples in pressures that simulate those found deep inside the Earth. New research reveals that magma can form much deeper in the planet’s mantle than previously thought. (Credit: Jeff Fitlow/Rice)


A team of scientists focused on the mantle beneath the ocean because that’s where the crust is created and “the connection between the interior and surface world is established,” says Rajdeep Dasgupta, assistant professor of Earth science at Rice University.  Silicate melts—aka magma—rise with the convective currents, cool and spread out to form the ocean crust. The starting point for melting has long been thought to be at 70 kilometers beneath the seafloor.

That has confounded geologists who suspected but could not demonstrate the existence of deeper silicate magma, Dasgupta says.

Scientists determine the mantle’s density by measuring the speed of a seismic wave after an earthquake, from its origin to other points on the planet. These waves travel faster through solids than liquids, and geologists have been surprised to detect waves slowing down through what should be the mantle’s express lane.

“Seismologists have observed anomalies in their velocity data as deep as 200 kilometers beneath the ocean floor,” Dasgupta says. “Based on our work, we show that trace amounts of magma are generated at this depth, which would potentially explain that.”

The research also offers clues to the bulk electrical conductivity of the oceanic mantle.

“The magma at such depths has a high enough amount of dissolved carbon dioxide that its conductivity is very high,” Dasgupta says. “As a consequence, we can explain the conductivity of the mantle, which we knew was very high but always struggled to explain.”

Deep, but not deep enough

Because humans have not yet dug deep enough to sample the mantle directly—thought some are trying—researchers have to extrapolate data on rocks carried up to the surface.  A previous study by Dasgupta determined that melting in the Earth’s deep upper mantle is caused by the presence of carbon dioxide. The present study shows that carbon not only leads the charge to make carbonate fluid but also helps to make silicate magma at significant depths.

The researchers also found carbonated rock melts at significantly lower temperatures than non-carbonated rock. “This deep melting makes the silicate differentiation of the planet much more efficient than previously thought,” Dasgupta says. “Not only that, this deep magma is the main agent to bring all the key ingredients for life—water and carbon—to the surface of the Earth.”

In Dasgupta’s high-pressure lab at Rice, volcanic rocks are windows to the planet’s interior. The researchers crushed tiny rock samples that contain carbon dioxide to find out how deep magma forms.

“Our field of research is called experimental petrology,” he says. “We have all the necessary tools to simulate very high pressures (up to nearly 750,000 pounds per square inch for these experiments) and temperatures. We can subject small amounts of rock samples to these conditions and see what happens.”

They use powerful hydraulic presses to partially melt “rocks of interest” that contain tiny amounts of carbon to simulate what they believe is happening under equivalent pressures in the mantle. “When rocks come from deep in the mantle to shallower depths, they cross a certain boundary called the solidus, where rocks begin to undergo partial melting and produce magmas,” Dasgupta says.

“Scientists knew the effect of a trace amount of carbon dioxide or water would be to lower this boundary, but our new estimation made it 150-180 kilometers deeper from the known depth of 70 kilometers,” he says.

“What we are now saying is that with just a trace of carbon dioxide in the mantle, melting can begin as deep as around 200 kilometers. And when we incorporate the effect of trace water, the magma generation depth becomes at least 250 kilometers. This does not generate a large amount, but we show the extent of magma generation is larger than previously thought and, as a consequence, it has the capacity to affect geophysical and geochemical properties of the planet as a whole.”

Researchers from Brown University and the University of Minnesota contributed to the study, which was supported in part by the National Science Foundation.

Source: Rice University