Pollinators: Evolutionary flower power

CORNELL (US) — Pollinators, including bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds, are agents of natural selection in flowers, enabling them to produce seeds for the next generation.

“It was assumed that pollinators drive evolution on floral traits because pollinators prefer certain floral characteristics,” says Andre Kessler, assistant professor of ecology and evolutionary biology at Cornell University.

“In this species, (foxglove beardtongue) we found that pollinators are the agents of selection on flower morphology [a flower’s physical characteristics],” he adds.

“These findings are important because it is only by understanding the agents of natural selection that we understand why evolutionary change occurs,” says Amy Parachnowitsch, the paper’s lead author and a former graduate student in Kessler’s lab.

Researchers allowed bees and other insects to pollinate the flowers of 150 beardtongues in a field and hand-pollinated the flowers on another 150 plants in the same field.

Since the hand-pollinated plants were not dependent on pollinators, they acted as a baseline of natural selection by other forces to which open-pollinated plants could be compared.

The researchers could then assess whether pollinators were exerting natural selection on seven floral traits tested by comparing the open-pollinated with hand-pollinated plants.

If pollinators were driving natural selection on floral traits, then they would have found stronger selection in the open-pollinated plants.

In fact, the researchers found that insect- or open-pollinated plants showed statistically stronger selection for two traits: larger and more flowers, proving that pollinators were the agents of selection for both these traits.

Details appear in the journal New Phytologist.

Also, for the number of flowers in open-pollinated plants, a phenomenon called stabilizing selection was at work—just as it isn’t good for human babies to be born too big or too small, it’s best for plants to have an intermediate number of blossoms in the open-pollinated plants.

Common sense suggests it is always better to have more flowers because having more flowers often leads to more fruits and seeds.

However, Kessler says there can be a cost for plants having too many large flowers—lots of large, showy flowers boosts the odds that flowers end up pollinating other flowers on the same plant. Showy displays can also attract herbivores that eat both seeds and flowers.

The stabilizing selection by pollinators keeps the beardtongues from evolving to have ever-bigger displays and, thus, plants avoid inbreeding, the researchers say.

The study was funded by the Botanical Society of America, National Science Foundation and Cornell’s Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology.

More news from Cornell University: www.news.cornell.edu