"The window has now passed," says Christopher Beard. "Field research like that which our team conducts cannot begin again until the country is stabilized and the personal security of scientific researchers in the field can be assured." (Credit: Dick Mooran/Flickr)


How the war in Libya snags fossil research

Researchers discovered mammal fossils from 30 and 31 million years ago in the Zallah Oasis in the Sirt Basin of central Libya. Their findings shed light on human evolutionary history—and how war can complicate scientific field work.

Since the 2011 toppling of Muammar Gaddafi, fighters tied to various tribes, regions, and religious factions have sown chaos across Libya, where the find took place. Most recently, ISIS militants there committed mass beheadings that triggered retaliatory bombings by neighboring Egypt.

“Currently, it is obviously very dangerous to be a Western scientist in Libya,” says Christopher Beard, professor of ecology and evolutionary biology at the University of Kansas. “Even Libyan citizens are not immune to random violence.”

Worth the risk

According to Beard, the paper sheds light on a poorly documented interval of our own evolutionary history—the early Oligocene—and shows climate and environmental change can utterly alter a local ecosystem—from a wet, subtropical forest in the Eocene to a dry desert today.

This knowledge makes taking calculated risks in a war-torn land worth the risk, he says.

“The most important factor is to have local collaborators who are experienced and who have a good feeling for what is impossible or dangerous,” Beard says. “Our Libyan collaborator is an experienced and highly accomplished professor of geology at Tripoli University. He has excellent ties to the Libyan petroleum industry, and he knows the Sahara Desert of Libya as well as anyone.

“We consulted closely with him prior to our 2013 expedition, and when he gave us the green light that it was safe to return to the country—thanks largely to his logistical arrangements with a local oil company—we felt safe about going back, despite State Department warnings against travel to Libya.”

Beard, who participated in both the Libyan fieldwork and subsequent analysis of the fossil finds, says taking care of logistics was the hardest part of the work.

“The arrangements were hard to put in place, because we had to coordinate among a team of four different nationalities, and we required the consent and active participation of our colleagues working at Zuetina Oil Company in Zallah,” he says.

Different fossils than in Egypt

Working in the Zallah Oasis in Libya’s Sirt Basin—an area that has “sporadically” produced fossil vertebrates since the 1960s—the team discovered a highly diverse and unique group of fossil mammals dating to the Oligocene, the final epoch of the Paleogene period, a time marked by a broad diversity of animals that would seem strange to us today, but also development of species critical to human evolution.

Beard says that the fossil species his team discovered in Libya were surprisingly different from previous fossils tied to the Oligocene discovered in next-door Egypt.

“The fact that we are finding different species in Libya suggests that ancient environments in northern Africa were becoming very patchy at this time, probably because of global cooling and drying which began a short time earlier,” he says.

“That environmental patchiness seems to have promoted what we call ‘allopatric speciation.’ That is, when populations of the same species become isolated because of habitat fragmentation or some other barrier to free gene flow, given enough time, different species will emerge.

“We are still exploring how this new evolutionary dynamic may have impacted the evolution of primates and other mammals in Africa at this time.”

No quick return

Unfortunately, ongoing strife in Libya makes a return visit to the Sirt Basin site impossible at the moment. Armed conflict in that nation prohibits outside scientists from visiting to safely conduct any kind of field research.

“The window has now passed,” Beard says. “Field research like that which our team conducts cannot begin again until the country is stabilized and the personal security of scientific researchers in the field can be assured.”

Because Beard’s work focuses on the origin and evolution of primates and anthropoids—the precursors to humans—he finds the Libyan discovery of a new species of the primate Apidium to be the most exciting of the fossils uncovered by the team.

“These are the first anthropoid primate fossils known from the Oligocene of Libya and the only anthropoid fossils of this age known from Africa outside of Egypt,” says the researcher.


“Earlier hypotheses suggested that anthropoids as a group may have evolved in response to the global cooling and drying that occurred at the Eocene-Oligocene boundary. Our new research indicates this was certainly not the case, because anthropoids had already been around for several million years in Africa prior to that boundary.

“But the climate change still had a deep impact on anthropoid evolution, because habitat fragmentation and an increased level of allopatric speciation took place as a result. Anthropoids, being forest dwellers, would have been particularly impacted by forest fragmentation during the Oligocene.”

The paper appears in the Journal of African Earth Sciences.

The Biological Anthropology Program at the National Science Foundation funded the research. Beard collaborated with researchers from Tripoli, University of Poitiers in France, and the Biodiversity Institute at University of Kansas.

Source: University of Kansas

Related Articles