The better the buzz, the more likely young binge drinkers are to develop drinking problems later in life, according to a new study.
The findings run counter to the idea that a higher tolerance is what drives alcoholism.
Researchers tracked how 104 young adults who are heavy social drinkers responded to alcohol and monitored their long-term drinking habits.
“Heavy drinkers who felt alcohol’s stimulant and pleasurable effects at the highest levels in their 20s were the ones with the riskiest drinking profiles in the future and most likely to go on and have alcohol problems in their 30s,” says Andrea King, professor of psychiatry and behavioral neuroscience at the University of Chicago.
“In comparison, participants reporting fewer positive effects of alcohol were more likely to mature out of binge drinking as they aged.”
As part of the long-term study, King and colleagues carefully screened and studied heavy social drinkers who reported a pattern of binge drinking behavior as young adults—at least four (for women) or five (for men) drinks per occasion, between one and five times per week.
Heavy vs. light social drinkers
A group of light social drinkers was used as a control. Participants engaged in three sessions, in which they were given a placebo drink with only the smell of alcohol, a low dose of alcohol, or a high dose. They then answered questionnaires, took performance and memory tests, and were sampled for levels of the stress hormone cortisol.
The initial assessment when the participants were in their 20s revealed that the heavy drinkers showed a strongly positive preference to alcohol, reporting greater stimulating effects, “liking” and “wanting more”, with lower sedative and cortisol effects. Participants were then assessed in regular follow-ups to track their drinking behaviors and symptoms of addiction over time.
Six years later, the heavy drinkers, now with an average age in their early thirties, fell into three distinct trajectory groups of alcohol addiction symptoms—high, intermediate, and low. (Light drinkers formed one low-risk drinking group over time with no addiction symptoms so they were not further examined.)
Searching for how those initially measured alcohol responses might predict which group the participants fell into, King and her team found that those in the high alcohol addiction symptom group reported far higher stimulation and pleasure from alcohol effects than members of the low or intermediate groups. Tolerance to alcohol’s fatiguing effects was less predictive of the future course of addiction.
The results are published in the journal Biological Psychiatry.
Moderate earlier, not later
“We knew that at age 25, there were binge drinkers who were sensitive to alcohol’s more positive effects,” King says. “We just didn’t know what was going to happen to them. Now we show that they’re the ones more likely to go on to experience more alcohol problems.”
King and her colleagues are now studying to see if early intervention in drinkers with a positive response to alcohol is effective. They also continue to follow participants well into their 30s.
“Those who drink heavily might want to pay more attention to their response to alcohol for important warning signs,” King says. “If you have sensitivity to the positive effects of alcohol, it might be better to moderate your use earlier than later.”
The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, the Alcoholic Beverage Medical Research Foundation, the University of Chicago Comprehensive Cancer Center, the National Center for Research Resources, the National Institutes of Health Roadmap for Medical Research, and the New York State Psychiatric Institute funded the study.
Source: University of Chicago