Teaching computers to think like Isaac Newton

pendulum

Professor Hod Lipson (left) and graduate student Michael Schmidt adjust a double pendulum. Reflectors on the pendulum enable motion-tracking software to record position and velocity as the pendulum swings. From this a new computer algorithm can derive equations of motion. (Credit: Lindsay France/Cornell University Photography)

CORNELL (US)—If only Isaac Newton could have gotten his hands on a supercomputer and a new algorithm developed by Cornell University researchers. He could have skipped the apples altogether. The new method helps computers find regularities in the natural world that represent natural laws.

Hod Lipson, associate professor of mechanical and aerospace engineering, and graduate student Michael Schmidt, a specialist in computational biology, have tested their method, or algorithm, on simple mechanical systems and believe it could be applied to more complex systems ranging from biology to cosmology. The method also could be useful in analyzing the mountains of data generated by modern experiments that use electronic data collection.

Their process begins by taking the derivatives of every variable observed with respect to every other—a mathematical way of measuring how one quantity changes as another changes. Then the computer creates equations at random using various constants and variables from the data. It tests these against the known derivatives, keeps the equations that come closest to predicting correctly, modifies them at random and tests again, repeating until it literally evolves a set of equations that accurately describe the behavior of the real system.

Technically, the computer does not output equations, but finds “invariants”—mathematical expressions that remain true all the time, from which human insights can derive equations.

“Even though it looks like it’s changing erratically, there is always something deeper there that is always constant,” Lipson explains. “That’s the hint to the underlying physics. You want something that doesn’t change, but the relationship between the variables in it changes in a way that’s similar to [what we see in] the real system.”

Once the invariants are found, potentially all equations describing the system are available: “All equations regarding a system must fit into and satisfy the invariants,” Schmidt says. “But of course we still need a human interpreter to take this step.”

The researchers tested the method with apparatus used in freshman physics courses: a spring-loaded linear oscillator, a single pendulum, and a double pendulum. Given data on position and velocity over time, the computer found energy laws, and for the pendulum, the law of conservation of momentum. Given acceleration, it produced Newton’s second law of motion.

The researchers point out that the computer evolves these laws without any prior knowledge of physics, kinematics, or geometry. But evolution takes time. On a parallel computer with 32 processors, simple linear motion could be analyzed in a few minutes, but the complex double pendulum required 30 to 40 hours of computation. The researchers found that seeding the complex pendulum problem with terms from equations for the simple pendulum cut processing time to seven or eight hours. This “bootstrapping,” they explain, is similar to the way human scientists build on previous work.

Computers will not make scientists obsolete, the researchers conclude. Rather, they add, the computer can take over the grunt work, helping scientists focus quickly on the interesting phenomena and interpret their meaning.

The research was supported by the National Science Foundation.

Cornell University news: www.news.cornell.edu

chat2 Comments

You are free to share this article under the Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported license.

2 Comments

  1. Austin B. Carter

    Propose an experiment to turn the external contours of a geofact into 3-D hardcopy with the
    SIGGRAPH System then enter this digital data into the Hod Lipson-Michael Schmidt engineering
    computer algorithm at Cornell University. I have a geofact stream cobble that has an erosion
    surface that suggests a Lorenz strange attractor. Sobriquet ” The Stream Scream”.

    ABC

  2. Austin B. Carter

    If Jan 8th experiment sucsessfull then propose fabricating an ablative, epitaxialy-laminated
    slipstream disk for use in evaluating airstream and/or water stream turbulence. In use
    and after a measured exposure time to an air slipstream or water flow, the ablation pattern
    should yield evidence of comparable turbulence amplitudes measured by the number of ablated
    laminations penetrated per unit exposure time.

We respect your privacy.