Syrian refugees in a boat

Expert says it’s dangerous for U.S. to turn away refugees

Immigrating to the United States can be a long, arduous process that presents challenging, and sometimes insurmountable, hurdles along the way.

For Syrians, who currently make up one of the single biggest refugee population in the world (aside from Palestinians), the ordeal is especially tough. Already subject to the most stringent screening process of any nationality of refugees, since the terrorist attacks on Paris, they—along with Muslims in general—have been demonized by some US politicians as a direct threat to national security.

“It would be a strong statement to our allies in Europe and our friends in the Middle East—the countries who are bearing that burden—by showing them that we’re willing to step up.”

It would be detrimental for the US to close its doors to Syrian refugees, says Kate Jastram, an attorney and an expert in forced migration at the University of California, Berkeley’s Blum Center for Developing Economies. Not only would it intensify America’s anti-Muslim reputation, but it would alienate the estimated 3.3 million Muslims living in the US, or those who hope to migrate here.

“If we start saying, ‘Your religion is more important than anything else about you—your character, the suffering you’ve gone through,’ this is a really dangerous and long road for the US to go on.”

The United Nation reports that since the Syrian civil war broke out in 2011, the number of registered Syrian refugees in the world has swelled to nearly 4.6 million. Only about 2,700 have been accepted for resettlement in the US, according to the Refugee Processing Center.

[How news about Muslims shapes public opinion]

The majority of Syrian refugees and asylum seekers are living in countries that neighbor their homeland—the UN reports that Lebanon hosts more than 1 million, which amounts to 1 in 5 people in the country, and Turkey hosts more than any other country worldwide at 2.5 million. Others have headed to Jordan, Egypt, and Iraq.

But Jastram says living in these countries is not usually a good longterm solution. “Often, refugees in countries of asylum don’t have a secure legal or economic status,” she says. “They become increasingly desperate just about living their day-to-day lives.”

So some Syrians have decided to make the often dangerous journey to seek resettlement in Europe. Germany has accepted some 93,000 Syrian refugees and has said it could take another 500,000 each year for several years, and France has promised to take 30,000 more Syrian refugees over the next two years.

100,000 Syrians

Although refugees seek asylum across the world, only 28 countries take part in the UNHCR’s resettlement program, which offers refugees legal and physical protection as they transition to their new homes.

The US is the top resettlement country. It has taken 70,000 refugees annually for the past several years and has upped the number to 85,000 in 2016 in response to the growing number of refugees, including the 10,000 Syrians the US has approved for resettlement in fiscal year 2016.

Although some conservative politicians expressed outrage at that number, Jastram says 10,000 is far too few.

“As a positive political measure, accepting 10,000 Syrians is not sufficient,” says Jastram. “I think it’s completely within the realm of possibility for the US to take at least 100,000 Syrians. It would be a strong statement to our allies in Europe and our friends in the Middle East—the countries who are bearing that burden—by showing them that we’re willing to step up.”

Canada, with one-tenth the population of the US, has committed to accepting 25,000 Syrian refugees in six months; nearly 14,000 have arrived there since November.

[Timing is crucial in Supreme Court immigration appeal]

Because Syrian refugees have to undergo such extensive security checks for US resettlement—it generally takes 18 to 24 months, and sometimes longer, to be accepted—people who want to cause the US harm wouldn’t enter the country as a refugee, Jastram says. They’d more likely come in on tourist visa or some other temporary visa.

“Refugees aren’t the problem. It seems to be more a difficulty of assimilating people. Of really welcoming and supporting them when they get here, sending the message that you can be Muslim and American.”

Immigrants, especially the children of immigrants, can have a hard time feeling truly integrated into American culture, particularly given rising economic and racial inequality, says sociologist and immigration expert Irene Bloemraad.

“Immigrants are often very thankful they were able to come to the US, so they’re willing to sort of look the other way when someone treats them unfairly. Children of immigrants, however, expect to be treated equally—like Americans—and when they’re not, there’s more potential for them to build feelings of resentment and alienation.”

As more Syrian refugees migrate to the US, Jastram says, Americans will naturally become more familiar with, and thus more accepting of, their Syrian neighbors.

“Usually, those who find asylum in the US become sort of ambassadors for the US by upholding America’s roots as an immigration country. I think as more Syrians start coming, it will happen again. People will see that they’re just people.”

Source: UC Berkeley