Two different groups of lizards—geckos and anoles—took two different evolutionary routes to developing their sticky toe pads.
Researchers report that anoles seemed to commit to a single type of toe pad, one that generates lots of friction. As a group, they were able to develop sticky toe pads early.
Geckos, meanwhile, opted for an evolutionary “drunken stumble,” and seemingly didn’t commit to a single approach, instead evolving toe pads that generate plenty of friction in some species and others that excel at sticking directly to a surface.
The stumbling theory, formally known as the Brownian motion model, best explains gecko evolution. Different groups of geckos sought various approaches and jumped at adaptive solutions. They achieved the beneficial traits by pursuing different ways, moving forward some eras and backward during others, says Travis Hagey, an evolutionary biologist at Michigan State University. Hagey and colleagues report their work in the journal Evolution.
Did anoles have but one option? Is there merely one evolutionary path to become the best tree-climbing lizard? Were geckos more laissez faire with evolution?
Evolution is a tinkerer.
“We’re trying to explain how evolution works and how predictable it is,” says Hagey, who’s part of Michigan State University’s BEACON Center for Evolution in Action. “Good science answers one question while producing more questions. Anoles and geckos are two different large groups of lizards. They live on different continents, and evolutionarily, they’re separated by 250 million years of time. So even though they have some of the same traits, you can’t assume that they were developed the same way.”
Evolution is a tinkerer, he adds. Hagey likens it to a person who lives on a dirt road and decides to build a bicycle.
“But they can use only the parts they can get their hands on and make modifications and repairs until they get a bike they like,” Hagey says. “Two different people might build two different bikes that both work well on dirt roads, but the process and steps they went through will probably be different. The same is true for geckos and anoles. They both evolved sticky toes but got there different ways.”
In a related paper in PLOS ONE, Hagey chose to focus on limb length. Geckos and anoles live on trees and climb vertical surfaces. They have to deal with the same mechanical aspects, but did they take different paths to gain those advantages? Did they evolve traits that emphasized sprint speed over balance or vice versa?
“Studying sticky toe pads and limb length helps scientists understand how and why animals are shaped the way they’re shaped and the mechanics of their movement,” Hagey says. “You’d think there would be only one good way to climb a tree or one good way to swim, but there are many.”
For both studies, Hagey traveled to locations in the Dominican Republic, Australia, and Thailand. Visiting a breeder in Oklahoma allowed him to observe 15 lizard species from five continents. Overall, his research reviewed 30 species of geckos and 20 species of anoles.
The study shows that geckos generally have shorter legs than anoles. The scientists are unsure why this is the case, but once they factored in the length difference they made an interesting observation.
Lizards living on bushes, regardless of geckos or anoles, have long tails, striped backs, and long legs. Those living on small branches in the canopy of a forest tend to be brown, with short tails, long snouts, and short legs. These traits were consistent despite being separated by oceans or hemispheres.
“Even though we were able to find some cool similarities, we really don’t know why, yet,” Hagey says. “Maybe they’re all adapting to be the best bush lizards or the best tree-climbing lizards and all heading toward the same evolutionary solutions.”
Coauthors of the paper in Evolution are from University of Idaho, Cambridge, the University of London, and Lewis and Clark College. Researchers from James Cook University (Australia) and the University of Idaho contributed to the PLOS ONE study.
The National Science Foundation and National Geographic supported the research.
Source: Michigan State University