Society & Culture - Posted by Steve Manas-Rutgers on Wednesday, October 24, 2012 9:26 - 2 Comments
Alums with disabilities cite campus pros and cons

"To level the playing field for people with disabilities by encouraging college education and completion, it is essential to learn the factors supporting degree completion," says study author Paula Barber. (Credit: "wheelchair user" via Shutterstock)
RUTGERS (US) — College graduates with disabilities attribute their academic success to a combination of strong personality traits and relationships with a faculty or staff mentor, a new study shows.
Accessing campus accommodations was not a major issue but learning about such help “was not always the smoothest process,” the report notes.
The research also determined that the students mainly used campus resources for assistance rather than a combination of college and community services. Additionally, investigators examined problems faced by college disability and special services offices, including record keeping and student-faculty outreach.
Straight from the Source
“The challenges students with disabilities face on college campuses are well documented but little is known about the experience of those students who successfully completed college,” says Paula Barber, a clinical social worker and senior research project manager at Rutgers’ John J. Heldrich Center for Workforce Development.
“To level the playing field for people with disabilities by encouraging college education and completion, it is essential to learn the factors supporting degree completion.”
One such factor, self-advocacy, increases the opportunity to become more competitive during job searches, Barber reports. “While it appears college enrollment for students with disabilities is increasing, the ability to secure employment at a level matching their educational attainment is often limited,” Barber says.
Despite passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act in 1990, federal research indicates that people with disabilities have a lower employment rate and higher rate of poverty and dependence on public social services support than their counterparts without disabilities.
They also complete college at a statistically significant lower rate than students without disabilities and those who do graduate have a persistent lower rate of employment irrespective of their level of degree attainment.
For the study, disabilities services staff identified students who completed their degrees between May 2008 and May 2012 or were about to do so. The participants’ disabilities included a wide range of physical, emotional, and cognitive disabilities, as well as dual diagnoses.
All thought their personal and financial investments in their education were “life changing” and worthwhile, Barber says. She adds that some were told by high school teachers that they were not “college material.”
The students learned about accommodations through a variety of on-campus sources, including classmates, academic advisers, deans, at community colleges, and by trial-and-error. Parents, high school special education classes, medical professionals and outpatient rehabilitation providers were among off-campus resources. Accommodations included classroom and test-taking help, tutoring, technology support, and counseling.
Twenty students from Burlington County College, Mercer County Community College, Raritan Valley Community College, New Jersey City University and Rutgers were interviewed for the study.
Among the report’s key findings:
- Students with disabilities who completed college reported using many services on campus and overwhelmingly attributed their success to a significant relationship with either a professional staff member at the Office of Disability/Special Services or a faculty member.
- Participants had observable personal qualities (self-awareness, perseverance, interpersonal skills) that allowed them to develop and maintain positive, long-term relationships with mentors, either on-campus on in their social circles. Their insight about their disabilities and ability to self-advocate were universally high.
- Although learning about accommodations was not a smooth process, access to accommodations was not a major issue.
- Participating colleges were significantly challenged in accessing service information on students with disabilities.
- Offices of Disability/Special Services are often underfunded, high-volume operations.
- Students and staff identified faculty training on their role in providing accommodations and in understanding how disabilities affect learning in the college classroom as in need of additional support and resources.
Barber says that because previous research suggests that only about half of students with disabilities at community colleges avail themselves of on-campus resources, questions about why students fail to use such resources must be answered.
She also recommends conducting research on the impact of college faculty and staff development on disability as a diversity issue and on best practices to facilitate the transition of students with disabilities to employment.
“Including disability as a diversity issue on college campuses has been very slow to be adopted, if at all, and merits serious attention if we are to meaningfully include people with disabilities on college campuses as students, faculty or staff,” Barber says.
Barber’s research appears in the Disability and Work research report, a joint publication of the Heldrich Center and the Kessler Foundation.
Source: Rutgers
Please wait
2 Comments
Jill
I believe students are basically unaware about the changes in the laws after they graduate high school. Child Study Teams are not properly transitioning students from high school to post-secondary. This lack of information to students and parents results in an ever-growing chasm once the student graduates from secondary school. This topic has become my passion.
@Jill, I advise instructors and support staff in colleges that although we cannot ask, “Do you have a disability?” However, after an assessment, the concerned party can legally say, “I see that you are struggling/having difficulty with this concept/work/etc; did you have any extra help in high school? Like extra time of tests or resource room classes?” If student says: yes, maybe, what do you mean? or even no, the concerned party can follow with, “I ask because we have an office on campus that maybe be able to help you with extra support services.”
























I wonder what the drop out numbers are for students with disabilities?
I can tell you a couple of reasons for why students fail to use such resources, both from helping a college age daughter with the process, and from working in an academic environment.
First – the programs are there. But in addition to finding out about them on your own; they take a lot of time. For example, in my daughter’s first year it took 3 months to process her to make her even eligible for any of the programs. Once approved – accessibility departments have the programs that will help with study, with accomodations, with tutorials and computer programs, notetakers etc. – but now students are into exams and final assignments. Where is the time for a student to attend these special programs and study as well? Students without disabilities have enough trouble finding time to study for exams. This part doesn’t really work.
Second – working in an academic environment, I am not allowed to recommend or even imply that any of the accessibility programs exist- period. It is considered discriminatory if I mention it to a student. Interestingly enough, I can recommend writing help programs, on campus tutorial programs, etc. to any student on a “did you know the university has…” basis. But unless accessiblily help is directly asked for – staff can’t even explain that it is available. Students must self advocate and not everyone who works on campus knows about the programs.
One thing that I would recommend to colleges, universities and government agencies is to develop a number of ‘local to the students’ programs (ie in their home towns) or given a week at the college or university that they will be attending that would take place early in the summer before a student goes away to school – this is when and where a student should be processed through and given access to the additional training or resources that will help them. That way they can start school with their already supports in place.