Comet dust coats Mercury with ‘invisible paint’

Carbon from passing comets has been building up on Mercury's surface for billions of years and may explain its dark surface, says Peter Schultz. "We show that carbon acts like a stealth darkening agent. From the standpoint of spectral analysis, it's like an invisible paint." (Credit: "black paint" via Shutterstock)

Scientists have long puzzled over the planet Mercury’s dark, barely reflective surface. Now they believe they have the answer.

New research suggests that a steady dusting of carbon from passing comets has slowly painted the planet black over billions of years.

On average, Mercury is much darker than its closest airless neighbor, our moon. Airless bodies are known to be darkened by micrometeorite impacts and bombardment of solar wind, processes that create a thin coating of dark iron nanoparticles on the surface. But spectral data from Mercury suggests its surface contains very little nanophase iron, certainly not enough to account for its dim appearance.

16,000 MPH

“It’s long been hypothesized that there’s a mystery darkening agent that’s contributing to Mercury’s low reflectance,” says Megan Bruck Syal, a postdoctoral researcher at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory who performed this research while a graduate student at Brown University.

“One thing that hadn’t been considered was that Mercury gets dumped on by a lot of material derived from comets.”

As comets approach Mercury’s neighborhood near the sun, they often start to break apart. Cometary dust is composed of as much as 25 percent carbon by weight, so Mercury would be exposed to a steady bombardment of carbon from these crumbling comets.

Using a model of impact delivery and a known estimate of micrometeorite flux at Mercury, Bruck Syal was able to estimate how often cometary material would impact Mercury, how much carbon would stick to Mercury’s surface, and how much would be thrown back into space. Her calculations suggest that after billions of years of bombardment, Mercury’s surface should be anywhere from 3 to 6 percent carbon.

The next part of the work was to find out how much darkening could be expected from all that impacting carbon. For that, the researchers turned to the NASA Ames Vertical Gun Range. The 14-foot canon simulates celestial impacts by firing projectiles at up to 16,000 miles per hour.

Stealth darkening agent

For the new study, published in the journal Nature Geoscience, the team launched projectiles in the presence of sugar, a complex organic compound that mimics the organics in comet material. The heat of an impact burns the sugar up, releasing carbon. Projectiles were fired into a material that mimics lunar basalt, the rock that makes up the dark patches on the nearside of the moon.

“We used the lunar basalt model because we wanted to start with something dark already and see if we could darken it further,” says Peter Schultz, professor emeritus of geological sciences and a coauthor of the study.


The experiments showed that tiny carbon particles become deeply embedded in the impact melted material. The process reduced the amount of light reflected by the target material to less than 5 percent—about the same as the darkest parts of Mercury.

Importantly, spectroscopic analysis of the impact samples revealed no distinctive spectral fingerprints, again similar to flat spectral signatures from Mercury.

“We show that carbon acts like a stealth darkening agent,” Schultz says. “From the standpoint of spectral analysis, it’s like an invisible paint.”

And that paint has been building up on Mercury’s surface for billions of years.

“We think this is a scenario that needs to be considered,” Schultz says. “It appears that Mercury may well be a painted planet.”

NASA’s Planetary Geology and Geophysics program and the NASA Earth and Space Science Fellowship program funded the work. Miriam Riner from the Planetary Sciences Institute was a coauthor on the paper.

Source: Brown University